Indeed, it's surprising that they made it onscreen at all, in their current form. Modern fantasy and sci-fi writers tend to be better at rejecting or reinventing the racist tropes embedded in the genre, and I doubt the goblins, in their current form, would make it past the final cut of a rebooted Harry Potter series. However, I think it would be unfair to suggest that this was an intentional display of bigotry Rowling clearly imbued anti-Semitic tropes in her reimagining of goblins, likely subconsciously, but thoughtless racist tropes are, unfortunately, all too common in fantasy and science fiction (the aliens of the Star Wars prequel trilogy are a good example of this phenomenon). But minting coins and money-lending? That’s all Rowling. Typically, in fantasy fiction, goblins are depicted as cruel, grabby, and untrustworthy, the type of creatures to join orcs in battle against the forces of good, to stab an adventurer with a rusty dagger, and steal their valuables. Rowling argue that the author was simply repeating folkloric tropes, but goblins featured in folktales are not found behind the desk of a bank.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |